The Best Stovetop Percolators for Making Killer Coffee

There is no shortage of ways to make a great cup of coffee. But there is something about the simplicity of the stovetop percolator. When used correctly, it can yield an unbeatable brew.

If you’d like to start making coffee with a stovetop percolator, you’ll obviously need find a percolator that suits your preferences. There are a plethora of percolators from which to choose, but this guide should make your selection process much easier.

Here are our picks for the best stovetop percolators:

Continue reading for a more detailed breakdown. Then, grab a mug and get to percolating.

The Best Stovetop Percolators

While these old-school coffee contraptions might have fallen out of favor for shinier methods like the automated drip coffee brewer, there’s a certain charm – and taste – you only get from brewing coffee in a percolator.

Here are three of the best stovetop percolators you can use to make a killer cup of coffee:

Faberware Classic Yosemite Stainless Steel Stovetop Percolator

You can’t go wrong with this timeless beauty. Convenient and durable with a mirror finish, the Faberware Classic Stovetop Percolator boasts a clear, glass knob so you can tell exactly when the percolating begins. It also has a permanent filter basket, so you’ll never have to worry about forgetting your filter.

Farberware 50124 Classic Yosemite Stainless Steel Coffee Percolator – 8 Cup, Silver,Stovetop
  • Classic coffee maker: Make delicious coffee morning or evening with The Original 8-Cup Farberware Stovetop Percolator
  • Durable and convenient: Heavy-duty stainless steel coffee maker is polished to a mirror finish. The sturdy, clear glass knob lets you know when percolating begins
  • No mess: Features a permanent filter basket, so there’s no need to deal with messy coffee filters
  • Dishwasher safe: Fully immersible and dishwasher safe except knob and pump tube spring, the percolator combines technology with the styling and quality Farberware has delivered for decades
  • Exterior Finish: Stainless Steel Interior Surface: Stainless Steel Lid Material: Stainless Steel with Glass knob

The Farberware Classic Stovetop Percolator definitely passes the wear-and-tear test. And boy can she brew. The permanent metal filter just lets minimal grounds through, making sure you don’t get that unwanted crunch in your mouth.

Elite Gourmet Classic Stovetop Percolator

Get your hands on the Elite Gourmet ECOO8 Classic Stovetop Percolator, and you can brew up to 8 cups of flavorful fresh coffee. And fast, too! It takes less than a minute per cup. This stainless steel beauty also comes with a 12-cup option. There’s a reason (actually, several reasons) its a top pick on Amazon.

Elite Gourmet EC008 Classic Stovetop Coffee Percolator, Glass Clear Brew Progress Knob, Cool-Touch Handle, Cordless Serve, 8-Cup, Stainless Steel
  • BREW UP TO 8 CUPS of hot, flavorful and fresh coffee or tea in less than a minute per cup. Utilizing the classic stovetop brewing process, you can brew fresh and full flavor beverages fast and easy.
  • GLASS BREWING CYCLE PROGRESS KNOB indicates when Coffee Is Ready. The Transparent Real Glass Knob allows you to view brewing cycle and includes Dishwasher safe Stainless Steel permanent filter basket.
  • OUTDOOR & INDOOR USE the durable 304 food grade stainless steel coffee percolator is built for use on an indoor stovetop or outdoor camping fire, perfect for travel use.

This percolator may not be perfect – some users claim that it perks coffee onto the counter. But make no mistake, this machine is built to handle your coffee needs like a champ. With a classic design using 304 stainless steel, the Elite Gourmet Stovetop Percolator makes a great addition to any kitchen. It’s also nice for percolating coffee in the great outdoors.

COLETTI Bozeman Camping Coffee Pot

The highest rated of the bunch, the COLETTI Bozeman Camping Pot comes from a veteran-owned company. And just like our veterans, this pot is tough. While it was engineered for the outdoors, it’s also perfect for your stovetop indoors.

COLETTI Bozeman Percolator Coffee Pot — America’s Favorite Percolator [9 cup]
  • NO ALUMINUM OR PLASTIC — Our camping coffee makers are toxin free, and make the best camp kitchen equipment. Don’t brew with lesser perculators that use aluminum and plastic. Choose a coffee percolator that will serve you well when you brew your camping coffee
  • EASIEST WAY TO MAKE CAMP COFFEE — A stainless steel camping coffee pot is simple, efficient, & classic. When you want something strong, and it’s too early for beer, brew with a Bozeman. The perfect stove top coffee maker
  • QUICK CLEANING ON THE TRAIL — A simple to clean percolator coffee pot that anyone can use. Just a quick rinse after every use and you’re good to go. No fuss and all function, leave the fancy stuff at home – Brew with a COLETTI cowboy coffee pot

COLETTI has become one of the premier outdoor coffee companies in the world, and they definitely strove for perfection when making the Bozeman Camping Coffee Pot. In fact, as COLETTI claims, “This is the last camping percolator coffee pot you will ever need.”

RELATED: How to Make Coffee with a Stovetop Percolator

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I choose a good stovetop percolator?

Aside from durability and quality, consider the capacity. If you live alone, for example, you probably won’t need a percolator that brews more than one cup at a time. But if you’re a coffee hog or you have roommates, you may want to opt for a percolator with a larger capacity.  

What makes percolator coffee better?

Stovetop percolator coffee is generally stronger, creamier, and more robust. Due to the hotter water and the longer brewing time, a percolator typically extracts more flavors from the coffee grounds.

Are there any drawbacks to using a percolator?

The two primary drawbacks to using a stovetop percolator are: over-extraction and attention.

Percolators can easily over-extract the coffee grounds which can result in a bitter taste. Consequently, brewing coffee in a percolator requires a bit more of your attention. You must be cognizant of both water temperature and brewing time.

Leave a Reply